- in terms of fine scale ancestry, the Erfurt Jews show enough variation to be divided into three or four clusters, as opposed to just two as per Waldman et al. - some of the Erfurt Jews show excess "Mediterranean" ancestry, while others excess "North African" ancestry, and this cannot be explained with ancestral populations similar to Lebanese and/or South Italians, but rather with significant gene flow from the western Mediterranean and possibly North Africa - several of the Erfurt Jews show relatively high levels of "East Asian" ancestry that cannot be explained by admixture from Russians, or even any Russian-like populations, because such populations almost lack this type of ancestry, and instead show significant "Siberian" admixture - as far as I can see, there are no correlations between any of the observations above and the quality of the samples. That is, low coverage doesn't appear to be causing the aforementioned excess "Mediterranean", "North African" and/or "East Asian" ancestry proportions.Investigating this in more detail with, say, formal statistics will take some time. But I was able to reproduce the results from the above ADMIXTURE run using several somewhat different datasets, so that's something. It seems to me that Waldman et al. want a simple and elegant model to explain the data, which is understandable, but I do think they should at least expand their ADMIXTURE analysis to include "Siberian", "Mediterranean" and "North African" clusters, and go from there depending on what they find. Citation... Waldman et al., Genome-wide data from medieval German Jews show that the Ashkenazi founder event pre-dated the 14th century, bioRxiv, posted May 16, 2022, doi: https://doi.org/10.1101/2022.05.13.491805 See also... Mediterranean PCA update
search this blog
Showing posts with label North Africa. Show all posts
Showing posts with label North Africa. Show all posts
Tuesday, June 21, 2022
My take on the Erfurt Jews
I had a quick look at the genotype data from the recent Waldman et al. preprint focusing on the ancestry of early Jews from Erfurt, Germany. My impression is that the genetic origins of these Jews are somewhat more complex than claimed in the manuscript.
Indeed, I'd say the Waldman et al. characterization of the Erfurt Jews as a three-way mixture between populations similar to present-day Lebanese, South Italians and Russians doesn't exactly reflect reality.
Unlike Waldman et al., I designed an ADMIXTURE analysis that separated East Asian ancestry into East Asian and Siberian clusters, and also included Mediterranean and North African clusters. The output is available in a spreadsheet HERE. Below is a bar graph based on some of the output.
Now, keeping in mind that ADMIXTURE is not a formal mixture test, and that it estimates ancestry proportions from inferred populations, as opposed to ancient groups that actually existed, here are some key observations:
Labels:
admixture,
ancient ancestry,
ancient DNA,
Ashkenazi,
Central Europe,
East Asia,
Eastern Europe,
Erfurt Jews,
Germany,
Jewish,
Jews,
Medieval,
Mediterranean,
Middle Ages,
North Africa,
Poland,
Russia,
Slavic,
Slavs
Sunday, November 10, 2019
Etruscans, Latins, Romans and others
I've just added coordinates for more than 100 ancient genomes from the recently published Antonio et al. ancient Rome paper to the Global25 datasheets. Look for the population and individual codes listed here. Same links as always:
Global25 datasheet ancient scaled Global25 pop averages ancient scaled Global25 datasheet ancient Global25 pop averages ancientThus far I've only managed to check a handful of the coordinates, so please let me know if you spot any issues. Below is a Principal Component Analysis (PCA) featuring the Etruscan and Italic speakers. I ran the PCA with an online tool specifically designed for Global25 coordinates freely available here. Can we say anything useful about the origins of the Etruscan and early Italic populations thanks to these new genomes? Also, to reiterate my question from the last blog post, what are the genetic differences exactly between the Etruscans, early Latins, Romans and present-day Italians? Feel free to let me know in the comments below. Update 13/11/2019: Here's another, similar PCA. This one, however, is based on genotype data, and it also highlights many more of the samples from the Antonio et al. paper. Considering these results, I'm tempted to say that the present-day Italian gene pool largely formed in the Iron Age, and that it was only augmented by population movements during later periods. The relevant datasheet is available here. Update 13/11/2019: It seems to me that the two Latini-associated outliers show significant ancestry from the Levant, which possibly means that they're in part of Phoenician origin. These qpAdm models speak for themselves:
ITA_Ardea_Latini_IA_o ITA_Proto-Villanovan 0.547±0.081 Levant_ISR_Ashkelon_IA2 0.453±0.081 chisq 7.573 tail prob 0.87027 Full output ITA_Prenestini_tribe_IA_o ITA_Proto-Villanovan 0.679±0.068 Levant_ISR_Ashkelon_IA2 0.321±0.068 chisq 7.222 tail prob 0.89033 Full outputThe Proto-Villanovan singleton is also a key part of the models. Dating to the Bronze Age/Iron Age transition, she appears to be of western Balkan origin. Moreover, her steppe ancestry is probably derived directly from the Yamnaya horizon.
ITA_Proto-Villanovan HRV_Vucedol 0.677±0.031 Yamnaya_RUS_Samara 0.323±0.031 chisq 10.397 tail prob 0.661174 Full outputThe cluster made up of four early Italic speakers can be modeled with minor Proto-Villanovan-related ancestry, but, perhaps crucially, it doesn't need to be. Indeed, judging by the qpAdm output below, it's possible that almost all of its steppe ancestry came from the Bell Beaker complex, and, thus, the Corded Ware culture complex before that.
ITA_Italic_IA Bell_Beaker_Mittelelbe-Saale 0.480±0.055 ITA_Grotta_Continenza_CA 0.411±0.042 ITA_Proto-Villanovan 0.109±0.084 chisq 10.294 tail prob 0.590205 Full outputTwo out of the three available Etruscans look very similar to the Italic speakers in the above PCA plots, and yet they show a lot more Proto-Villanovan-related ancestry in my qpAdm run. The statistical fit is also relatively poor, perhaps suggesting that something important is missing.
ITA_Etruscan Bell_Beaker_Mittelelbe-Saale 0.186±0.081 ITA_Grotta_Continenza_CA 0.283±0.064 ITA_Proto-Villanovan 0.531±0.126 chisq 17.175 tail prob 0.143143 Full outputInterestingly, the Etruscan outlier with significant North African admixture (proxied in my run by MAR_LN) doesn't need to be modeled with any Bell Beaker ancestry.
ITA_Etruscan_o ITA_Proto-Villanovan 0.675±0.057 MAR_LN 0.325±0.057 chisq 14.864 tail prob 0.315912 Full outputUpdate 17/11/2019: The spatial maps below show how three groups of ancient Romans (from the Imperial, Late Antiquity and Medieval periods) compare to present-day West Eurasian populations in terms of their Global25 coordinates. The hotter the color, the higher the similarity. More here. See also... Getting the most out of the Global25
Labels:
admixture,
ancient DNA,
Ancient Greece,
Ancient Rome,
archaeogenetics,
Etruscans,
Global25,
Italic,
Italy,
Latin,
Levant,
Mediterranean,
Middle East,
North Africa,
Pontic-Caspian steppe,
Roman Empire,
Southern Europe
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





